• About Amy Welborn
  • Homeschooling
  • Travel
  • Sex & Gender
  • Lent

Charlotte was Both

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« More Angela
Hey, Colonizer »

TGIT

January 28, 2022 by Amy Welborn

Well, not thank goodness, but yes, because apparently every freaking day is Transday.

If you have been reading me on this for a while, you know that one of the primary lenses through which I see this issue, aside from the basic one of…uh, no, you can’t change sex, idiots, is in terms of the impact on and reflection of the experiences of women and girls.

I‘ve written on it quite a bit.

The three cases I have for you today – all of which I’ve written about before – are excellent examples of this, as well as of the insanity and incoherence of “gender identity.”

Because in all three, you’ll see either the recognition, rights or safety of women and girls being sacrificed for the needs and desires of males.

And as you read them – especially the first two – keep asking….why should one guy’s desires prevail over the rights and safety of women and girls?

  • I wrote about “Hannah” Tubbs here. Well, he was sentenced this week.

A Los Angeles County judge on Thursday ordered Hannah Tubbs, a transgender California woman, to serve two years in a juvenile facility after she pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting a 10-year-old girl in 2014. 

Before doing so, the judge criticized far-left District Attorney George Gascon, whose office declined to prosecute the repeat offender as an adult.

Tubbs, 26, recently pleaded guilty to molesting the girl in a women’s bathroom eight years ago when Tubbs was two weeks away from turning 18. At the time of the crime, she identified as male and went by James Tubbs. She did not identify as female until after she was taken into custody, according to prosecutors.

“Tubbs is 26 years old. Unlike George Gascon’s false narrative, she is not a ‘kid,'” L.A. Deputy District Attorney Jon Hatami, assigned to the Complex Child Abuse Unit, told Fox News Digital.

 “There was evidence presented at the juvenile proceedings which showed that Tubbs sexually assaulted two young girls in different incidents in the past. The child victims will suffer lifelong trauma. Tubbs also has prior violent convictions and conduct as an adult.”

Because Tubbs began identifying as female after she was taken into custody, and Gascon refused to try her as an adult, Tubbs was sentenced to two years in a juvenile facility.  In L.A. County, juvenile facilities can house both females and males, but in separate areas. Tubbs will be housed with the females. 

Tubbs sexually assaulted a female child as a juvenile male. Now well into adulthood, he is to be housed in a juvenile facility with girls.

Literally insane. I mean…literally insane.

And a deep violation of the rights of these girls. But you know – if a dude claims he’s a girl, that’s the most important factor in a situation, isn’t it?

  • Oh, Lia Thomas. Previous written about in this space here, here and here.

You will be shocked to hear this:

A member of the University of Pennsylvania women’s swim team said some team members are uncomfortable changing in the locker room with transgender swimmer Lia Thomas, according to a teammate.

Thomas, 22, who spent the previous three years swimming with the men’s team before she began transitioning to a woman, has created an uneasy environment in the locker room, as she still retains her biologically male genitalia – which are sometimes exposed – and is attracted to women, one teammate told the Daily Mail in an interview.

“It’s definitely awkward because Lia still has male body parts and is still attracted to women,” the swimmer said. Thomas has reportedly told her teammates that she dates women.

The swimmer told the outlet that other team members have spoken to the team’s coaches about possibly getting Thomas to change elsewhere from the rest of the team, but those discussions haven’t gone anywhere

“Multiple swimmers have raised it, multiple different times,” she said. “But we were basically told that we could not ostracize Lia by not having her in the locker room and that there’s nothing we can do about it, that we basically have to roll over and accept it, or we cannot use our own locker room.”

“…her male genitalia.”

Again. Literally insane.

A quick note – I must correct something I said in a previous post. I said that Thomas had been taking female hormones. No, he hasn’t. He’s been taking testosterone suppressing drugs.

So get this. I mean, just settle down and get this:

A guy who has been, you know, a guy since conception, started taking some testosterone-suppressing agents a couple of years ago, grew his hair out, still has his penis and testicles…

and we all have to bow to him and call him a woman? And women have to just scoot over and give him room to swing himself around in their presence?

No.

****And remember, that I cite these examples, not just as discrete headline-grabbers, but to continually encourage you to be brutally logical, follow the path of reason where it leads, and allow yourself to ask questions about the trans issue in general.

If you are not on board with Lia Thomas calling himself a woman and taking up a woman’s space, if you’re looking at Hannah Tubbs and thinking, opportunistic sociopath, you must ask yourself why and you must understand that contemporary trans activists are all about breaking down any biological criterion for sex determination and will accept nothing less than gender self-identification. Which means….I declare myself whatever gender, no medical, psychological or legal gatekeeping allowed and you must affirm me.

  • Finally, yeah.

Or rather, no.

No.

(Note that Schneider was previously married to a woman and is presently in a relationship with a woman.)

When Caitlyn Jenner announced his inevitably doomed campaign for California governor, I wondered if he won (which I new he wouldn’t, but you know, thought experiment), if he’d be heralded as California’s first woman governor. I mean…given the times, how could he not?

Again, this is not headline-picking for a slow Friday.

This issue is presented to us overwhelmingly, in terms of emotion, using the vaguest of definitions, along with hand-waving, gaslighting and manipulation.

Resist. Keep asking the hard, but simple question: What makes Tubbs, Thomas and Schneider “women?”

And then perhaps, Why should society, and especially women’s spaces, restructure themselves to accommodate these men’s desires?

(Reminder why I don’t use “preferred” pronouns.)

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Amy Welborn | 12 Comments

12 Responses

  1. on January 28, 2022 at 10:33 am Carrieanne

    Well at least Jenner strongly opposes Lia Thomas swimming as a woman and even calls it unfair to other women swimmers! https://www.foxnews.com/media/lia-thomas-penn-swimmer-caitlyn-jenner-ncaa-rule-change-hannity


    • on January 28, 2022 at 6:36 pm Mary Smith

      There is also this: https://www.swimmingworldmagazine.com/news/petition-launched-to-urge-usa-swimming-to-prioritize-fairness-in-womens-sports/


      • on January 28, 2022 at 7:03 pm tejanagringa

        That’s one of the few things giving me any hope in all this.


  2. on January 28, 2022 at 6:56 pm Mary

    Amy, thank you so much for your continued reporting on the trans issue. I agree 10000000% and cannot understand why parents of female athletes are not uniting against this whole nightmare and doing something about it. The parents must be so frustrated. Have you heard if there is anything like this going on? Please keep writing and telling stories. I love your reflections in Living Faith.


  3. on January 28, 2022 at 9:10 pm Marianne

    At least it looks as if Tubbs will be separated from the female juvenile inmates:

    “Because Tubbs is now recognized in California as a female, she will be housed with other female juveniles at the facility where she will be transferred. However, [Attorney Justin W. Clark, who represented LA County in the case] said Tubbs would be housed alone.”

    https://nypost.com/2022/01/27/hannah-tubbs-sentenced-to-california-juvenile-detention-facility/


    • on January 30, 2022 at 10:26 am Mom

      The statements are contradictory. If you read the whole article, you hear how both the prosecution and the judge blame each other for failing to act when in reality either party could have prevented this mess.

      I’d wager that in a few months we’ll hear that Tubbs continued to assault juveniles in prison. Sickening.

      And who is funding all this nonsense? BLM funds this organization: http://www.tgijp.org/


  4. on January 29, 2022 at 12:34 am Deborah F

    I found when I said to women friends that Amy Schneider is not and can never be the “winningest” woman on Jeopardy because Amy Schneider is a biological man, I was met with somewhat embarrassed silence, as though I were saying something vulgar and transgressive or gossiping rather than simply stating what would seem to be an indisputably indifferent and obvious fact. There was never any remark other than “this will ruin women’s sports”, said meekly and with eyes downcast with what looked sort of like shame at saying it out loud.. It is facts and “the truth” itself that are at challenge here, don’t you think, as well as protections for women. Challenges to such a thing as “the truth” have something to do with opposition to the Kingship of Jesus Christ in a big comprehensive way, I suspect, somewhat dimly. There is something under all this insistence and compliance that I can’t quite get to and comprehend. I can’t see where it is meant to go by those cultural powers driving it..Your writing on this subject has been helpful to me, thanks.


  5. on January 29, 2022 at 11:15 am Nerina Bellinger

    Deborah, good for you for stating the obvious and thank you for being a voice of reality! The embarrassed silence with which your statement was greeted is precisely the reaction the transactivists have been cultivating and I’m sure it will progress to proud condemnation of anyone stating such obvious truths. I will not be silent about this issue. Transgender ideology is destroying our young people – particularly our girls – and if I have to suffer some uncomfortable interactions with people for my saying so, then so be it. I don’t know if Amy has talked about Abigail Shrier’s book, Irreversible Damage, in a previous post (I imagine she most likely has) but I highly, highly recommend it for anyone trying to get their hands around this quickly metastasizing issue.


    • on January 29, 2022 at 7:51 pm Amy Welborn

      I have! https://amywelborn.wordpress.com/2021/07/21/irreversible-damage/


      • on January 30, 2022 at 5:56 pm Nerina Bellinger

        I KNEW you would have done, so I did a search on your blog and found the relevant post. This action led me to find other posts you’ve written and has also given me new books to read. Thank you, Amy, for taking on this issue as it appears there are too few voices in the Church (at least in my local church) willing to do so.


    • on January 29, 2022 at 7:51 pm Amy Welborn

      And I love the phrase “metastasizing issue.” Perfect.


  6. on January 30, 2022 at 6:13 pm Deborah F

    I just read your 7/21/21 post, Amy, thank you!



Comments are closed.

  • Header Image

    Death Valley, 2015

  • Now Available!




  • Books on Saints
  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 9,694 other subscribers
  • It is what it is


    stories
    opinions
    observations
    photos.
    reviews

    Seeker Friendly.

  • Check out the new Substack
  • Fiction

    A short story about mothers, daughters, and why we believe what we say we believe…or not. 

    "amy welborn"

    Finalist for the J.F.Powers Short Story Award. Read on  Wattpad. 

    A novel

  • My son's novel
  • Hola.

    Amy Welborn
  • Follow Charlotte Was Both on Facebook. Get new posts in your newsfeed. Save wear and tear on the Internets.

    Follow Charlotte Was Both on Facebook. Get new posts in your newsfeed. Save wear and tear on the Internets.
  • In the past

  • Follow Charlotte was Both on WordPress.com
  • Copyright Notice

    © Amy Welborn and Charlotte Was Both, 2007-2023 Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited.

  • amywelborn.net

    amywelborn.org

  • INSTAGRAM

  • Last year at the beginning of Lent, I posted a section from a late 19th-century book called The Correct Thing for Catholics.  As I said at the time, Aunt Agnes would never in a million years become a Romanist or be seen in the environs of a Papist gathering, but still. Because I was watching The Gilded Age, I couldn’t help but hear all of these admonitions in Aunt Agnes’ voice. Today is the feast of St. Margaret Clitherow. Linked is a post on her, and attached are a couple of images -  from the entry on her from the Loyola Kids Book of Saints, and the others from her shrine in York, which I visited last summer: There is more than one kind of death, and there is more than one kind of tomb in which the dead parts of ourselves lie, dark and still. Jesus stands outside every one of those tombs. His power is stronger than the stone, stronger than any kind of death. He stands; he desires our freedom; and to each of us he calls, “Come out!   On Flannery O'Connor's 98th birthday, a post with photos of her home at @andalusiafarm  as well as links to much of what I've written about her over the years.  Images from the Loyola Kids Book of Catholic Signs and Symbols, the Loyola Kids Book of Bible Stories, and the new Loyola Kids Book of Seasons, Feasts and Celebrations related to the #Annuncation.  From my 2020 Book of Grace-Filled Days. It's the Feast of the Annunciation - a few pages from my books related to the feast.  Most are published by @LoyolaPress. For more: Me on a certain element of John Wick 4. You can...probably guess which one.  Some thoughts on #solotravel and the #emptynest which of course turns into a Big Ol' Metaphor...

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Charlotte was Both
    • Join 453 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Charlotte was Both
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: