• About Amy Welborn
  • Books by Amy Welborn
  • Travel
  • Sex & Gender
  • Homeschooling

Charlotte was Both

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Walking Together
A Sundry Church »

Contented with stories

September 20, 2021 by Amy Welborn

What is the cost of lies?

It’s not that we’ll mistake them for
the truth. The real danger is that
if we hear enough lies, then we no
longer recognize the truth at all.
What can we do then? What else is
left but to abandon even the hope of
truth, and content ourselves
instead… with stories.

In these stories, it doesn’t matter
who the heroes are. All we want to
know is: who is to blame?

Kid #5 and I have been watching the HBO/BBC 5-episode series Chernobyl (at his request). I’m “enjoying” it (as much as one can enjoy a series about near-global disaster, official deceit, and human suffering) – it’s well-constructed and the Soviet 80’s vibe is fascinating, and you also have five hours of Emily Watson looking extremely concerned and Jared Harris (Lane!) being thoughtfully frazzled and throwing back vodka shots.

Widely praised, with some critics – most instructive to me was this, from the New Yorker – on what the series got wrong about the Soviet system. The series’ focus is about lies, secrecy and authority, but this writer says it doesn’t go far enough and creates a “truth-teller against the establishment” narrative in a system where that was largely impossible.

The Soviet system of propaganda and censorship existed not so much for the purpose of spreading a particular message as for the purpose of making learning impossible, replacing facts with mush, and handing the faceless state a monopoly on defining an ever-shifting reality.

(See, in another context, Fargo, season 3.)

Be that as it may.

The point is the rise of narrative over any sense of objective truth. There are deep roots of this, aside from human beings’ self-protective defense mechanisms. And you see it all over the place. And you see it, especially these days, when we are all overwhelmed by information. Who can dig through all the data available to us and determine truth on our own? Who has time? Who has the skills and understanding? Much easier to develop and narrative and stick to it.

It’s much easier to get people on your side by developing an emotionally-appealing narrative and push it, unrelentingly, and then vilify those who dare to question and dig.

As series creator Craig Mazin said: “The lesson is that lying, arrogance, and suppression of criticism are dangerous.”

This self-protective narrative construction can happen anywhere – in personal conversations, on social media, in institutions.

It’s fairly simple to identify, more challenging to combat. How to identify?

If the response to your question or inquiry is to call you a name, characterize you according to some identifier or alliance, or, more seriously, seek to expel you from whatever form of civilization is at stake – there you go.

And of course, social media, especially Twitter, lends itself to this tendency quite effortlessly and perhaps purposefully.

Even on Catholic Twitter (should I even say “even?” No reason to…) – the narrative-shaping, manufacturing of consent, caricatures and excommunications are constant – and as McLuhan says, there’s that media shaping the message again, because when you have 280 characters, who has time to present a case?

Slapping on labels – that is, creating the story – then pointing and laughing at whoever we’ve declared is to blame is much, much easier.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Amy Welborn | 2 Comments

2 Responses

  1. on September 20, 2021 at 5:04 pm Nicholas

    “…for the purpose of making learning impossible, replacing facts with mush, and handing the faceless state a monopoly on defining an ever-shifting reality.”

    This sort of thing makes me think of the Fatima warning that Russia would spread her errors throughout the world, since the whole world seems now to be devoted to this sort of ideological mush.

    Yeah, I know, Fatima is one of the many third rails of Catholic discourse, and I’m not making any claims about the secrets or the consecration or any of that. The warning just makes the situation we’re in now more eerie to me.


  2. on September 21, 2021 at 9:15 am Amy Welborn

    I absolutely agree with you I really do. It’s why I tend to shy away from dramatized biographies and historical pieces – set in a period, yes, but purporting to dramatizing a specific event – no, for exactly the reasons you say. We’ve got one more episode to go, and I’ll say that what I like are the individual scenarios of the impact of the explosion on human beings, workers and so on. But episode 4 ended with Emily Watson declaring “Someone’s got to tell the truth!” and….yeah. That happened….



Comments are closed.

  • Header Image

    Farne Islands, 2022

  • It is what it is


    stories
    opinions
    observations
    photos.
    reviews

    Seeker Friendly.

  • Email: amywelborn60 AT gmail

  • Books for Sacrament Season
  • Essay: Abiquiu
  • Essay: Guanajuato
  • Review: Mrs. Davis
  • Now Available!




  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 9,696 other subscribers
  • Check out the new Substack
  • Fiction

    A short story about mothers, daughters, and why we believe what we say we believe…or not. 

    "amy welborn"

    Finalist for the J.F.Powers Short Story Award. Read on  Wattpad. 

    A novel

  • My son's new novel
  • Hola.

    Amy Welborn
  • In the past

  • Follow Charlotte was Both on WordPress.com
  • Follow Charlotte Was Both on Facebook. Get new posts in your newsfeed. Save wear and tear on the Internets.

    Follow Charlotte Was Both on Facebook. Get new posts in your newsfeed. Save wear and tear on the Internets.
  • Copyright Notice

    © Amy Welborn and Charlotte Was Both, 2007-2023 Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this site’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited.

  • amywelborn.net

    amywelborn.org

  • INSTAGRAM

  • https://amywelborn.wordpress.com/2023/05/31/her-salutation-sings-in-the-stone-valley/ https://amywelborn.wordpress.com/2023/05/24/a-catholic-laywomans-viewpoint/ St. Bernardine of Siena's sermons (his memorial is today) are still timely. The excerpts below are on possessions (specifically clothing) and justice. Mother's Day at Mass: @angelusnews published a piece I wrote about one day in my trip to #Guanajuato #Mexico #catholic #faith #travel #solotraveling #travelingsolo #inspiration Today's the feast of St. Athansius. Some thoughts below, more at the link, along with link to the study guide I wrote years ago to B16's General Audience talks on the Fathers of the Church: I'm in Dappled Things this morning: Images are from the Loyola Kids Book of Bible Stories and the Loyola Kids Book of Catholic Signs & Symbols. Today is the feast of Catherine of Siena

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Charlotte was Both
    • Join 455 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Charlotte was Both
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: