• Home
  • About
  • Amy’s Books
  • Links and Blogroll

Charlotte was Both

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« In case you were wondering…
Blown away »

Of Gods and Men

May 1, 2011 by Amy Welborn

You’ve given your life to Christ.

Handed it over.

What now?

Of Gods and Men is about several things, but I think in the end, it is about that.

I’m not a Trappist, I don’t live in Algeria, I don’t live in an environment in which my life is threatened, but as I sat in the theater late afternoon on Good Friday watching this film, that is what I thought of, that is how I entered the story of these martyrs.

Je reste.


There is so much cultural cotton candy, so much bubble-gum flavored penicillin marketed to Christians these days, so many prescriptive, leaden, paint-by-numbers books and movies, that the really good stuff that honestly attempts to bring life-as- it -is in conversation with God-as-He-is is either ignored or shunned.

I went to see Of Gods and Men knowing the story and ready to appreciate it, but my expectations were confounded because I ended up blown away.

It’s a beautiful film, filled with unique, gorgeous faces, striking images and simple moments, resounding.

The story is compelling enough in itself, just on the surface.

(Here – if you like – go read a piece I wrote on the film for our neighborhood blog. Written to encourage folks to go see it, not just for the film’s sake, but also for the theater’s. Businesses tend to leave our area, not come to it, and this relatively new theater is doing what no other in Birmingham is doing – showing art, foreign, and independent films – we are trying to do what we can to encourage people to patronize it. So the blog post is written for a general audience. Read it to get the story, get the conflict, and then come back.)

But the gift of the film is to take the question – do we stay or do we go? – and to present to the audience in all of its complexity.

For the question is just that – do the monks, threatened by Islamist violence – stay or go?  It would be so easy to leave. So easy. To just go back across the sea to France.

But would it, really? Be so easy?

Each of the monks must work it out.  They each begin from a different place. Some determined to stay, others ready to leave, still others not so sure.  They talk, they pray, they think it over.

Je reste.


Here’s the thing about Of Gods and Men:  The life of the disciple of Jesus Christ is presented with great care, respect , and truth.  As a Facebook friend wrote, ” It is amazing to me that such a theologically pitch-perfect movie could ever get made.“

For me,  the pitch-perfect note that sounded the most strongly were the very intense conversations about death. About how a Christian faces death. They say: We have given our lives to Christ. They are already his. And the statements of one of the monks that no,  he was not afraid of death for,  “I am a free man.”

(Read Galatians if you don’t get it.)

Je reste.



Of Gods and Men is also a lesson in liturgical prayer.

I think that anyone who is involved in spiritual formation or liturgy should see this film and reflect on it. Anyone who talks or thinks about prayer. Which is most of us.

These men in Thiribine,  they are monks.  Which means,  of course,  that they pray the Hours,  they celebrate Mass ,  and that they chant.

The chant, the formal communal prayer permeates the film. To quote myself from the other blog post:

Each of these men struggle with a decision and a direction. They wash dishes, they talk, they bind wounds, they plant seeds, and all the time they are thinking over this pressing question. And then several times a day, they put down their hoes, lay aside their instruments, close their books and then quietly vest in white robes, gather in their small, plain chapel.  A bell is rung, their leader – Father Christian – raps the wood of a bench, they bow deeply, and together, they begin to chant. This  chapel isn’t a place of escape. It’s a place where they enter even more deeply into the struggle at hand, consciously entering into it, they would say, rooted in the body of Christ, there in the Algerian hills. I’ve never seen this connection – between prayer and life – expressed so profoundly on film.

So here’s what they don’t do: they don’t sit in a circle and extemporize.  Their “authentic” prayer is not prayer that they make up on the spot in their own style of speaking referencing only the specific issues at hand.  They pray the prayer of the Church which they accept as their own prayer.

St. Paul wrote we do not know how to pray as we ought.  What that means is that we don’t know what to pray for. We don’t know what is best for us. He follows that by assuring us …but the Spirit itself intercedes with inexpressible groanings.

That Spirit? Lives in the Church.  We do not know how to pray as we ought, but the Spirit, through the prayer of the Church, leads us, guides us, gives us the words.

Flannery O’Connor wrote in a letter: So many prayer books are so awful, but if you stick with the liturgy, you are safe.

I always take that to mean – safe from yourself, from your solipsism and short-sightedness.

Safe in the arms of God, guiding you where you need to be.

Strengthening you to suffer with those who suffer. With the crucified.

Je reste.

Do you know what that means?

It means -

I will stay.

Advertisement

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Print

Like this:

Like
One blogger likes this post.
  • Jason

Posted in Uncategorized | 11 Comments

11 Responses

  1. on May 1, 2011 at 8:06 am Joseph

    Thanks for this review – it was an amazing film that moved me deeply. My other favorite scene was the conversation between Brother Luc and the young Muslim woman about how one knows when one has fallen in love. What a profound perspective on the question.


  2. on May 1, 2011 at 10:12 am John G.

    The dvd will be available from Amazon in July.


  3. on May 1, 2011 at 1:22 pm Michael Tinkler

    On my list to watch as soon as I get back.


  4. on May 2, 2011 at 4:03 am David Collins

    Je reste

    Thank you for translating. And thoughts on the movie!


  5. on May 2, 2011 at 1:02 pm Dan

    This story is powerful. Thank you for your thoughts.

    I am struck today by meditating on the witnesses of these men who achieve what we describe as a Christian victory and compare it to the news of the last 24 hours in which another purported victory is described.

    These men achieved victory not by violence or its use in the face of self-defence (I am unclear which martyr has used such a tool). Yet, this victory is likely to ring through the millenia and other batlles will be forgotten in a generation.


  6. on May 2, 2011 at 1:02 pm priest's wife

    putting it in my Netflix queue….


  7. on May 4, 2011 at 6:36 am Clayton

    My first attempt to describe the film was to say, “It’s like Into Great Silence, set in a war zone.” If that doesn’t pique your curiosity…


  8. on May 4, 2011 at 1:12 pm Jason

    It’s been in my Netflix queue and my wife was preparing to have a baby when they were showing it in our local theater in Eugene…I so can’t wait to see it. Something tells me this is going to be one to share with our youth next year too…Thanks again for a great post and making me want to see this movie even more…God bless you Amy!


  9. on May 5, 2011 at 8:39 pm Margaret Catherine

    Went to see it today, in advance of heading up a group to see it next week. Phenomenal movie, and definitely in the same mold as Into Great Silence. Je reste. That determination to stay and be rooted where one is, to continue the work at hand whatever happens – that’s something we could all use a bit of.


  10. on May 5, 2011 at 11:38 pm Steve McCue

    Amy,

    This was the last movie I saw with my wife, Mary, who suffered for the last 16 months from pancreatic cancer. We saw it just 15 days before she died. Thus I find your meditation on the film’s theme of living in the face of death particularly insightful and comforting.

    My beautiful wife of almost 30 years was blessed with enough effective chemotherapy and energy to live most days until she died being fairly active and continuing to do work she truly cared about. In her own way, she answered the question posed by this film. And almost every day we prayed together, and I gave her the Eucharist. I was with her the moment she died. What a gift to us both!

    As a final sign of grace, she died on Easter Sunday, the day of Resurrection!

    Blessings,

    Steve

    P.S. I’ve enjoyed your blog almost from the day you started it.


  11. on May 6, 2011 at 3:26 pm Amy Welborn

    Steve:

    Thank you so much for your comment. God bless you.

    A



Comments are closed.

  • It is what it is



    stories
    opinions
    observations
    photos.
    reviews



    Seeker Friendly.


  • The Other Blog




  • Available on 2/7






    February 7.
    Random House links has excerpts.

  • Now available







    An article from the Long Island Catholic about Ann & the book - featuring a photo of her presentation of the mock-up of the book to the Holy Father.
  • Current and Recent Reads





  • Recent Comments

    Owen on Body of Christ
    Owen on Body of Christ
    The Sheepcat on Body of Christ
    Amy Welborn on To clarify
    Alicia on To clarify
  • Mass Translation Mania!

    A page on The How-To Book of the Mass



  • In the past

  • Header Image

    Glass hour d'ouevre picks from my parents's house. Lent doesn't start til 2/22. Party on...

  • Hola.

  • Short Takes

    • Epilogue of my book http://t.co/qcHhEhCc: The LOCAL view in Barcelona! (From Hospital Sant Pau) #FriFotos #Spain http://t.co/TXl6pDG8 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 24: That last evening on the beach at Cava d'Aliga. Hints of the next stop. Saying Yes. #Sicily #Italy #FriFotos http://t.co/sSg9Wc0k 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 23: Splashing in the water after a LOCAL shower in Siracusa. At Shrine of Our Lady of Tears. #Sicily #FriFotos http://t.co/TnmLkw7M 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 22: Seaside Mass, offered by the LOCAL parish for tourist season.The end of a very weird day. #Sicily. #FriFotos http://t.co/TFAHVzcI 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 21: Living like a LOCAL Italian tourist in Cava d'Aliga. #italy #sicily #FriFotos http://t.co/XSg5U9Uv 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 20: on the way to the SE coast. The steps of Caltagirone. (Site of my parking ticket). #FriFotos #Sicily http://t.co/9GUY7J3d 1 hour ago
    • Chptr 19 of http://t.co/qcHhEhCc: Cefalue duomo where I was stopped by LOCAL modesty police. #sicily #italy #Frifotos http://t.co/XnZXkapZ 1 hour ago
    Follow @amywelborn2

Blog at WordPress.com.

Theme: MistyLook by Sadish.


loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.