• Home
  • About the blog
  • Amy’s Books
  • Extended Blogroll

Charlotte was Both

Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Unconverging

September 23, 2007 by Amy

For those of you following the Emergent/Missional church in the US (which probably isn’t too many of you, but ah well..), this is interesting:

So Mark Driscoll of Mars Hill Seattle has now officially called Rob Bell of Mars Hill Michigan (along with Brian McLaren and Doug Pagitt) a heretic.

And here:

Then, Mark Driscoll spoke.  Excellent stuff.  I watch Mark’s Vidcast every week.  If I could pick a church as a backup church to attend other than Life Pointe, Mars Hill Church would probably be the place.  In watching, listening, and reading his stuff, I’ve had a mental picture that he is a 6′4″ trucker looking guy.  I guess he’s about 5′6″?  So, my mental picture of his persona was off a bit…though he still comes off truckerish, engaging, funny, abrasive, and insightful.

With that said, he has HUGE words for the Church.  He talked about:

  • the difference between the three streams of the emerging church (the relevants, the Emergents, and the confessional contextual calvinists).
  • how that Brian McClaren, Doug Pagitt, Rob Bell are basically sell outs when it comes to Scriptural integrity.  He presented a strong case and held nothing back.  Interesting stuff.  Without a doubt, this is the most direct, I’ve heard Mark address these issues.
  • He specifically cited their views on the Atonement, views on homosexuality,rabbinical study, their influences, and theology.
  • There were some very vivid conversations and references to the virgin Mary [from Amy: I think he means, specifically, the Virgin Birth] and McClaren’s new organization, “Deep SHIfT”.
  • Most importantly, he spoke of how there is a generation of people on the scene now who have no historical knowledge of the Church and how we must engage them.
  • If we fail to do so, the Church will continue to compete for an ever shrinking circle of angry children of liberal or fundamentalist religious people.

Brian McClaren’s new book is out in a couple of weeks – I’ve read it and did a brief review of it a few weeks ago, but I’ll have a more detailed look when it’s published. I’ve read through Rob Bell’s book on sexuality:  Sex God: Exploring the Endless Connections Between Sexuality and Spirituality and wasn’t exactly blown away by it. Not nearly as “radical” as the buzz would have you believe, and, most fascinating to me, no treatment of procreation. And you know, if you’re treating the connection between sexuality and spirituality, that small matter of how, in sex, God works through our interconnected lives and bodies to, you know..make new human beings…might be important.

A lot more here, at the Emerging Grace blog – she has listened to the podcast of Driscoll’s talk, outlines it, and asks for comments.

Posted in Religion | 5 Comments

5 Responses

  1. on September 23, 2007 at 3:51 pm Travis Johnson

    I actually meant the “virgin mary” though it was in reference to the virgin birth. Ultimately you have to listen to the audio to see what I’m talking about. I’d try to repeat it but, it would be totally taken out of context and misunderstood…not trying to skirt what was said. I simply would do an injustice to what was said and I don’t won’t to come off as vulgar.


  2. on September 24, 2007 at 5:45 pm Jenny

    fri… Driscoll was raised Catholic


  3. on September 25, 2007 at 2:27 pm John

    If you can successfully divorce sex from procreation, if you can convince a generation of youth that you can talk about a Christian view of sexuality without talking about children, then sex no longer has to be between one male and one female then, right?


  4. on September 26, 2007 at 12:54 pm BarbaraKB

    As Catholic, it is *extremely* important for us to understand this new movement within American Christian circles.

    Thank you, Amy, for your continued posting.

    Peace.


  5. on September 26, 2007 at 1:55 pm O

    And the emergent church was going to be so different from the established boomer status quo church of their parent’s generation but what have we? More Protestants protesting and splitting up. Next decade, or sooner, it will be the remergent church. I know a number of Catholics who follow these men on a regular basis. For me, hey, there’s a reason (or twelve) that I left that behind for the Church Jesus instituted (which is imperfect enough…). ::thrive! O

    O | onionboy.ca (art & faith) | luminousmiseries.ca {faith & art}



Comments are closed.

  • Saints





  • Prayer

    That all people of good will, especially those who make political and economic policies, may commit themselves to care for all creation.

    That believers of every religion may witness through their lives and through dialogue that the Name of God brings peace.


    Pope Benedict's General and Missionary Prayer Intentions for the month of November.
  • Amy’s Recent Books



    Come Meet Jesus

    Coming January 2010 from Word Among Us Press










    Available now!


    Sample chapter here
  • Best Of

    I once thought and still think that an encounter with monasticism challenges everything that we think about life and our purpose here in the great exile.

    May 2007
  • Books for Sale



    Buy from Amy's Bookstore



    A page on The How-To Book of the Mass



  • Recent Comments

    John Thayer Jensen on Randomness
    Lynn on Randomness
    Lynn on Randomness
    Chantell on Randomness
    Ali on Randomness
  • brain/storm



    stories
    opinions
    observations
    photos.
    reviews



    pointe

    Seeker Friendly.


    Contact Information

  • Triptych

  • Current and Recent Reads












    Hey, FTC! Yeah, the publisher sent me that one. So are we good now?



  • In the past

  • Blogging Around

  • Twits Found Here

    • Tomorrow going to tackle the e-book thing and win. published 2 hours ago
    • Wrote Living Faith for Kids devotionals this morning. Now: karate, etc. published 8 hours ago
    • Amazing rain. Nonstop. published 2 days ago
    • Am finally seeing the Twitter retweet function. Am a little confused. published 2 days ago
    • Big chunk of revision has disappeared. SO aggravating. published 2 days ago
  • Header Image



    Near Racalmuto, Sicily

Blog at WordPress.com.

Theme: Mistylook by Sadish.